The Replacement

Xander-angst! Last season, Xander was a misfit. He wasn't in college, he couldn't keep a job, he was at loose ends and stagnating. This episode, right at the beginning of season 5, is a logical counterpart to Dawn's "Real Me." In both, the core issue is one of identity. "Real Me" introduces Dawn's search for identity; "The Replacement" makes Xander's struggle with finding his groove as an adult into an explicit theme.

So he's twins--grown-up, responsible Xander and goofy, unreliable Xander. The twist is they are both Xander, and the clearest evidence of that is that the reliable one is doing things--getting a promotion, getting a nice apartment--based on the actions of season 4 Xander, who must have quietly been doing some of the right things in order to have the opportunities he takes advantage of in this episode.

As happens in other places, most notably the yellow crayon speech, Xander calls on his history and relationship with Willow. Despite Oz, Tara, Anya, and Dark Willow--Xander and Willow's bond is deep...arguably deeper than his bond with Buffy despite his loyalty and infatuation with her (Note, I'm excluding the last couple episodes of the series when I say that--but it's worth mentioning that he takes the side Willow is on when they throw Buffy out). True Xander, deep down, Willow knows him.

Two bits of foreshadowing occur: first, somewhat jokingly, Joyce complains about a headache. Yep, that's going nowhere good. secondly, Riley has a revealing talk with "responsible" Xander explaining that he knows Buffy doesn't really love him. The clock is ticking on that relationship, we suspect, AND we see Xander doing something that he does even more once he embraces his grown up side: he is the confidante who sees more than most people, and who is willing to say the hard things.

The resolution is simple, and Xander is restored. The Scoobies reaffirm their partnership by working together to solve the problem, and the Magic Box is established as a home base. Season continues to build from here.

Something Blue

Time for a fan fav because it's just so fun--as Willow tries to magically zap the pain of Oz leaving, she causes mayhem for everyone around her...which ends up comic, no harm done. BUT...this is far more than just a detour from the season's Big Bad. In significant ways, this episode foreshadows huge shifts in the characters and the series as a whole, especially later seasons when the whole vibe is much darker.

Here's a question: who's journey is the focus of "Buffy, the Vampire Slayer?" Based on the title, it's reasonable to say that Buffy's evolution and actions are the crux of the show, but...not so fast. Because she's "the chosen," because her prime directive can't change and her course is predestined, there are some pretty clear parameters. Yes, they play with "Buffy should go away to college" and "When Buffy gets married and has kids...." but really? Those violate the universe that Buffy exists in--and yea, I know at the end of the series, we can discuss if Buffy has found a way to beat the system, pulling a Kobayashi Maru. We're several seasons away from that discussion, though, so the question stands: who is the series really tracking?

Willow. I can make a serious argument that Willow's journey and evolution are in significant ways what gives the series depth and momentum. The clearest images of the episode may be Spike and Buffy getting engaged, making out non-stop as magically blinded Giles tells them that he can hear the smacking of their lips. But why is Buffy sitting on Spike's lap? Willow felt jealous and rejected, and---oops--magic happened. Xander, Amy, Anya, Spike, Giles, Buffy--they all feel the ricochet of Willow's inability to deal with negative emotions and reliance on magic as a mystical band aid.

D'Hoffern, the boss of vengence demons, tries to recruit Willow--that's not a wake up call to Willow that she has issues dealing with negative emotion, but it foreshadows to the audience that Willow's issues are not solved by the handing out of fresh chocolate chip cookies, which she's sweetly and humbly doing as penance at the end: "Eat a cookie, ease my pain" with the wistful little-girl, how-can-you-be-mad smile. Buffy's comment about possibly wanting a forgetting spell to erase her feelings for Spike is especially pointed; Willow loses Tara, then turns completely dark, because of the sequence of events from using forgetting spells. For every Scoobie character, this episode is a template of what happens in some significant ways in the next few seasons.

Giles is blind--yep, his solo in "Once More With Feeling" echos that sentiment; because he loves Buffy, he's blinded to what he needs to do to let her grow up. And, more immediately, he's not seeing clearly about his role since he left the high school.

Xander is a demon magnet--again, significant points are made about he and Anya's relationship, which is still in a fledgling stage. And although the yellow crayon is not referenced (the touching speech he gave to Willow when she went evil, ultimately saving her...and the world, of course), Xander is the one who tries to reach out to Willow in her pain, before anyone realized that she was inadvertently casting spells.

Spike and Buffy, well--they are crazy in love, planning their wedding--and arguing, not really liking each other, but still incredibly connected...sound familiar? When they do start a "relationship," Buffy doesn't like him, they argue constantly, she admits she's using him, yet the connection is strong. Pretty much a mirror image of the show, down to the intensity of the physical relationship.

And the short bit where Buffy talks to Riley about being engaged, then later explains it away? We see her with a "nice, normal guy" and get to imagine what if that would work...the idea of Buffy settling down in a suburb with a mini-van and a hunky husband is appealing, and this episode juxtaposes life as a Slayer--and a vamp boyfriend--with the "what if" image we get from Riley...so far.

The title is interesting. Obviously, the wedding is referenced: something old, something new, something borrowed, something blue. But...D'Hoffern is blue--the underlying point of the episode could be that connection between Willow and the potential she has for evil as symbolized by D'Hoffern. And blue can be shadowy, dark--this episode seems innocuous, but really, it's also shadowy and dark, simmering beneath the surface.

I like this episode. The dialogue is snappy and fun, the out-of-character actions work thanks to both strong writing and good acting, and overall, the structure is tight. But the more I think about it, the deeper it is, and even little lines have a great deal of significance in the context of the series as a whole. I suspect I'll reference this one again.

Earshot

This is an infamous episode, the episode that was delayed because of the Columbine school shootings. That's too bad, because the threat of violence really isn't an important part of the story--well, it is, but not why it's significant.

Buffy gets demon blood on her, then gains a trait of the demon--telepathy. She "hears" what others are thinking. At first, that's fun. She impresses her English teacher with insightful, unusual interpretations of Shakespeare and she finds out that her mom and Giles....on the hood of a police car...twice! But even as it's fun, it's revealing. When Buffy scores points with the English teacher, we find that Willow really doesn't think Buffy's very bright, for instance.

Buffy expects to have power; Buffy expects to be in control. In some ways, everyday ways, Buffy is clueless and whiny and plays "girl" very well, but deep down, she wants to be in control and powerful. An aspect of that is what this episode explores: Buffy has the power to know everything, essentially--and the power will kill her. She wants to use her power for good (a la Angel much later as he takes over Wolfram & Hart), trying to save the student body from the unnamed "killer," but instead, she is also in need of rescuing.

How many times will Buffy play out this scene: Buffy is the strong, powerful one who will solve the problem, only to finally concede that her power comes in part from her friends. Ironically, many times in the show, she desires knowledge of what they are thinking while keeping her thoughts and feelings bottled away.

And of course, Buffy recovers in time to save the day--only not. Ultimately, Xander does by realizing the lunch lady, not Jonathon, is the threat. Buffy gets the big, flamboyant action scene while Xander's just dorky, dumping over tables and yelling--he's not suave superhero, but boy doing the right thing.

And Buffy gets her version of the yellow crayon speech as she talks Jonathon down--insightful and all, but notice that later, she won't go to prom with him bc he's short, etc.

And Angel lurks in the background, Buffy's shadow and savior--as unreadable as ever, touting Buffy trying conversation and honesty instead of trying to read his thoughts.

Consequences

Basically, part two of Bad Girls. Faith tries to frame Buffy--which is when we realize exactly how bad Faith really is--and she threatens to kill to escape from the council when their goons (lead by Wesley) kidnap her.

I suspect I should rewatch this one too, but perhaps the most interesting thing is the Angel/Faith connection. After Buffy and Angel manage to capture Faith, she's shackled in Angel's mansion. He talks to her at length in a scene that is paced differently than the rest of the episode. Although he is not successful in getting through to Faith--and might even be called whining and stoically emo--he's just set the stage for Faith's redemption on his show in the next season (or two? I'm not sure of time frame). In the Buffy-verse, this is the beginning of a significant relationship; Angel champions Faith later, when Buffy claims to intend to kill her.

When I rewatch, I want to pay close attention to Buffy's costume and color choices. If I remember right, when she's being bad with Faith, she's in black--much like Faith typically is. After the killing and subsequent actions, Buffy seems to be in black/white outfits often. That's obviously used symbolically, but I'd like to watch it to see if there's more to say.

Also, Xander tries to do a yellow crayon intervention here, building on the "connection" he claimed to make with Faith in The Zeppo. Even though Buffy apologetically tells him that she knows it means nothing to Faith, Xander the faithful has to try--and nearly gets strangled to death by Faith for his efforts.

Importantly, Willow is having issues in this episode. She's trying to be the nice girl, but she's found out the Xander had sex with Faith and Buffy has been bonding with Faith--as much as Willow likes Oz, she's feeling like the odd man out. In this episode, a wordless shot in a montage shows Willow alone, sobbing--a strong visual counterpoint to her daffy, chipper persona. This time, Willow is the one who's jealous; Willow is the one who feels isolated--and she's aware that she's feeling these things even as she tries to be the good girl.

The Zeppo

I've seen this several times, and thought of it as a fun night in Xander's life, a chance for him to have the spotlight a bit. The structure reminds me of teen movies: a night in the life, leading to an older and wiser protagonist. There have been a couple heavy episodes, and we're heading into a couple more heavy ones (I think), so this is the respite.

Wow. I missed a lot. Still processing this one, in fact. First, remember the beginning of the series? How many Xander-centric episodes there were? He was goofy, he was serious, he was Everyman, he was Joss and the writers....

Then, he was Love Interest. The goofy-ness abated some as his wardrobe cleaned up a bit and Cordelia polished the rough edges--a bit. He was an integral part of the team, and had Buffy's back solidly.

This episode seems to begin the process of marginalizing him and redefining him. The last few episodes, Willow has come more into her own, becoming "The Witch." She's smart, but not nearly the brainiac she'd been in ways; beginning with Lovers Walk (maybe the one before; I'd need to look), she's turning to magic instead of other means to solve problems.

That leaves Xander as the odd man out. Giles has unique training and skills; Willow has magic; Buffy is the Slayer; Oz is a werewolf...and Xander? He's in danger, and clumsy, and--more strongly now than before--the punchline. He's also the reason the others are doing what they do: symbolically, Xander is the Everyman Sunnydale resident that they are protecting.

The episode has wonderful dialogue, and Nick Brendon's comic timing as well as his ability to evoke pathos are well used. The conversation about how to be "cool"--the laconic, ultra cool Oz (Seth Green) and the over-excited, rambling Xander is both insightful and hilarious. The conversations between Xander and Cordelia which bookend the episode mark the change between Xander the hapless spurned boyfriend and Xander on the road to manhood, laconic and cool, able to walk away from Cordelia's truthtelling (She is one of the most subtly named characters--a nod to King Lear, fulfilling her namesake's legacy in this episode).

And yes, this is the episode where Xander first saves Faith as she fights, then loses his virginity to her in a sweetly funny--and abruptly telling--couple of scenes. But that's not what made him a man tonight: standing up to Jack O'Toole, getting O'Toole to admit that he wasn't ready to really die--"janitor sweeping up pieces" dead, instead of zombie dead, coolly claiming he wouldn't "mind the silence"--that prototype to the famous yellow crayon speech in season 6 is the moment we see the Xander that lies beneath. For the next couple seasons, he is marginalized, but all through, the Xander who sees (as Caleb will note in season 7) is evolving. He has an almost parallel life to the mystical Scoobies in ways--and when Buffy points out to the council in season 5 that Xander has logged more field time than they all have put together, he puffs up with pride because he is often overlooked as a contributing member of the team. The habit of dismissing Xander's abilities as a Scooby are underscored, and in ways begin, with this episode.

Notably, Buffy and the others are in a parallel, apocolyptical plot which is only alluded to. In a fascinating structural tour-de-force, we see key moments, startling emotional, violent pastiche of imagery, with no context as Xander bumbles in the way of whatever Buffy et al are fighting. It's fun, and the story comes to a conclusion with them glad Xander was "safe," never looking at him hard enough to see the differences that Cordelia and the audience mark. The audience notes the team feel of the battered veterans around the table, with Buffy fapparently forgiving Giles for his betrayal last episode--and Xander sees them much more clearly than they see him--not for the last time, either.